New York Casino Voter Referendum Wording Challenged by Attorney

New York Casino Voter Referendum Wording Challenged by Attorney

  • Posted: Feb 21, 2020
  • By:
  • Comments: 0

A New York State casino referendum for voters has one attorney questioning the ballot’s wording november

In November, New York voters are scheduled to vote on a referendum that would allow several casino that is new to be built through the entire state. But if one Brooklyn lawyer is successful, that referendum will be halted due to language within the ballot question that he claims violates state law.

Referendum Language Questioned

The language in the referendum carries a amount of ‘legislative purposes’ that paint the proposition in a light that is unmistakably positive. For example, the concern mentions ‘promoting task growth, increasing aid to schools and allowing neighborhood governments to lower property taxes.’ That language was authorized by the State Board of Elections in July.

But now, lawyer Eric J. Snyder is contending that the language in the bill violates New York legislation. Based on case filed within the nyc State Supreme Court, Snyder alleges that the language violates the continuing State Constitution’s prohibition on the utilization of public profit the aid of ‘private undertakings.’

‘The Constitution is pretty clear that you can’t use money that is public sway or influence a vote,’ Snyder said.

Snyder isn’t the one that is only has brought up problems with the language in the referendum. Many government watchdog groups also view it as one-sided, and groups that are religious also noted the language used whenever telling parishioners to consider social ills that could come with the advertised advantages of casino expansion.

Interestingly, the first language in the referendum did not mention any of the benefits which are set to seem in the ballot question that is final. When the draft that is first from their state attorney general’s office, the language was more direct and didn’t include the legislative purposes. Those showed up only after the Board of Elections changed the wording, after exactly what co-chairman Douglas Kellner said had been ‘extensive conversations.’

Wording Can Affect Outcome, Historically Speaking

The language of a ballot question might seem just like a thing that is trivial battle over, but history indicates time and once again that even minor changes to the name or wording of legislation may have an important effect on public opinion, and who has proven real once more in this case.

According up to a poll by Siena university, 55% of New York voters were in favor associated with the referendum when these people were read issue because it is scheduled to show up on the November 5 ballot, with 42% compared. But when voters were instead asked a question that is similar more neutral language, they certainly were evenly split on the issue.

That ‘advocating language’ is what Snyder who also opposes casino expansion physically states should cause the court to enjoin voting on the bill until more neutral language was place in its destination.

‘It is partisan, and an effect is being had by it,’ Snyder stated. ‘And that’s not the federal government’s part.’

The success of the referendum is in some doubt regardless of the language used despite the promising poll numbers. Without any elections that are statewide for November, turnout is probably to be low in many towns. However in nyc, a mayor that is contested race will probably lead to higher turnout there and voters in the town tend to be more skeptical about the casino expansion than voters in all of those other state.

For Tribal Gaming Lobby, It’s a row that is tough Hoe in Congress

Scenes such as this one, of tribal gaming lobbyists working their dilemmas in Congress, don’t seem to be producing results that are many times

An awful lot of people are unhappy with the direction or absence thereof of the United States Congress this year. Now you can add indigenous American tribes that operate gambling enterprises across the united states compared to that list that is long.

No Respect in Congress for Tribal Issues

Discussing the lack of any federal legislation to clarify and regulate the brand new relative Wild West that is state-by-state online gambling in the U.S. these days, John Gusik a founding partner of the Washington D.C.-based law and government relations services outfit called the Franklin Partnership, had this to say during the recent international Gaming Expo (G2E) in Las Vegas: ‘There were 4,500 bills in Congress this year; only 31 have been enacted. It is a do-nothing Congress. Seventy-two bills dealing with tribal issues and none have already been enacted. Web gaming continues to languish in Congress.’

Whilst the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act of 1988 established the framework for Native American gambling enterprises to benefit this until-then underclass economically, it has not all been champagne and flowers for many of the tribes, who still grapple with basic dilemmas such as better education and health care with regards to their members. And now as legal online poker in Nevada and imminently, legal online casino gambling in New Jersey and Maryland simply take hold the Indian ‘special nation’ status vis a vis casinos could be threatened, specially as gambling industry executives warn of impending market saturation throughout the majority of the U.S. that will affect the whole marketplace.

Demonstrably, all the drama surrounding health care and also the government shutdown hasn’t exactly helped put concentrate on Indian casino industry issues either.

Casino Money Isn’t Enough, Lobbyists Insist

The nationwide Indian Gaming Commission showed $27.9 billion in gaming revenues in 2012, which is up 2.6 percent from $27.2 billion in 2011, so that the tribes may have trouble garnering much sympathy from anybody in a still unsteady economy, but lobbyists says there is much more at stake for the tribes than simply revenue.

‘If you represent tribes, they think you must work on Indian gaming on a regular basis,’ said Pete Kirkham, who runs Red Maple Consulting, a federal government affairs and governmental strategy firm, and works with many of the tribes on different legislative issues. ‘ Gaming takes up some time but it’s also about wellness care, education and housing.’

Kirkham says they are nevertheless waiting on 13 appropriation bills that the tribes significance of funding. He says that while almost all of tribal income is gaming-derived, that much of it goes directly back to the community.

‘Everything is now seen through the prism of video gaming,’ said Jana McKeag, president of Lowry Strategies, an Alexandria, Va., government and public affairs consulting firm. ‘Congress believes that tribes have all this video gaming money … why do they need (federal dollars)?’

Other problems that tribal lobbyists want addressed involve the profusion of off-reservation casinos in areas where those casinos might take business far from the Indian ones. Also, the proliferation of online cafes in states like California, Florida, and new york have emerged as an issue the whole gaming industry must deal with.

‘In California, for example, they’re unlawful but the state does not have any cash to shut them down,’ McKeag noted regarding the panel that is g2E. ‘These are typically not regulated and can be an window of opportunity for cash laundering. The thing is when they shut them down, they just appear somewhere else.’

Meanwhile, with everything taking place in Congress today, it doesn’t look like tribal gaming issues will likely move to leading of the relative line any time in the future.

Gambling enterprises Ready to Add Nostalgia-Based Skill Games to Their Rosters

Slot manufacturer IGT has reintroduced the Centipede that is old game slots to touch to the nostalgia craze

They offer, casinos are usually careful to limit just how much players can affect the games through their own skill when it comes to the games. Sure, blackjack and video poker offer players the chance to make skillful choices, but even perfect play nevertheless renders the casino with a little advantage (and if you overcome that through card counting, they could always just stop permitting you to play). Most other games, like slots, are completely based on random luck.

Everything Old is New Again

But with casinos seeking new avenues with which to attract customers, it appears as though skill-based video gaming may be coming to a venue towards you. That’s your message from the gaming that is global (G2E), where manufacturers had been showing off games that allow players to make use of their skills in an effort to give them a better possiblity to win cash.

The biggest hit that had been seen at G2E in this genre is a device developed by Overseas Game Technology. IGT has made a machine in line with the 1981 hit game that is arcade, in which players shoot virtual insects to be able to score points.

Centipede had been originally developed by Atari, an ongoing company that has long since passed its heyday. But IGT as well as other manufacturers are hoping to cash in on a wave of nostalgia that may lure middle-aged gamblers whom have fond memories of playing early games that are arcade.

In the casino form of Centipede, the points that players score could possibly be directly translated into money. Needless to say, the casino nevertheless wants to have the benefit, so that you’ll have to get fortunate to get into bonus rounds and even the absolute most player that is skilled be an underdog over time against the casino.

Playing Against Other Players on Machines

But that’s not where games like Centipede intend on stopping. The device also enables two players to go head-to-head on the machines, utilizing the better player walking away with the winnings. That’s a true battle of skill, similar to just how players can fulfill one another at the poker table, with the casino taking only a cut that is small ensure they profit.

Middle-agers aren’t the ones that are only IGT and other manufacturers (WMS and Aristocrat both say they have skill-based games in the works) are hoping that these games can pull in; these businesses also want to lure younger players to slots, which traditionally have now been the bailiwick of an older demographic. A few new games by Bally Technologies even incorporate leader boards in order in an attempt to get players right back in the habit of wanting high ratings.

‘The casino would love it if players are like, ‘Oh, I got beat! I have to go back and play some more to get into the lead,” stated Bally spokesman Mike Trask. ‘if they were 15 years old in 1985 playing against their friends, trying to get the score that is highest, that person is practically 50 years old now, in addition they’re right in the demographic.’

Others believe that the main element will be players that are matching head-to-head skill contests with money at risk. This has become a reality in online video gaming, and some see casinos could do the exact same thing.

‘Let me play Madden football, let me play EA Hockey,’ said Geoff Freeman, head of the American Gaming Association. ‘ We’ll place $20 down, the winner gets $15 and the house gets $5.’

However, casino experts point out that these sorts of experiences will probably only add up to a niche market in the industry. In the end, they do say, casinos nevertheless make a lot more money when gamblers play they take on each other against them than when.